Skip to content

Chapter 5: CSIRT Operations and Incident Response Tools

Learning Objectives

By the end of this chapter, students will be able to:

  • Delineate the specialized roles and responsibilities within a Computer Security Incident Response Team (CSIRT), including the distinction between command and technical functions.
  • Construct a communication and escalation matrix that ensures timely stakeholder notification during a crisis while maintaining operational security (OPSEC).
  • Evaluate and select appropriate forensic tools for memory, disk, and network analysis, including specific utilities like Volatility, KAPE, and Eric Zimmerman’s tools.
  • Analyze the detailed architecture of Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) platforms, specifically contrasting Splunk and the Elastic (ELK) Stack.
  • Design SIEM correlation rules and utilize User Behavior Analytics (UBA) to detect anomalies.
  • Apply rigorous documentation standards, utilizing specialized case management tools to maintain confidentiality and Chain of Custody.

5.1 Advanced CSIRT Roles and Responsibilities

In the previous chapter, we introduced the CSIRT as a concept. Now, we must operationalize it. A functional CSIRT operates much like an emergency room: everyone has a specific job, and crossing lanes can cause chaos. The effectiveness of the response relies heavily on clearly defined roles.

5.1.1 The Command Staff

  • Incident Commander (Incident Lead): The IC is the ultimate authority during an active incident. Their primary responsibility is coordination, not investigation. The IC isolates the technical team from management pressure, manages the timeline, and approves all major decisions (e.g., "Do we shut down the e-commerce server?").
  • Communications Coordinator: This role manages the narrative. They draft internal updates for employees and external statements for customers, partners, or the media, ensuring that no unauthorized information leaks.
  • Legal and Compliance Liaison: This individual ensures that the technical steps taken by the team (such as intercepting employee email traffic) are legal and that regulatory reporting timelines (e.g., GDPR's 72-hour window) are met.

5.1.2 The Technical Staff

  • Security Analysts: These are the first responders who perform triage. They review SIEM alerts, filter out false positives, and determine the scope of the incident.
  • Forensic Investigators: These specialists deal with evidence preservation and deep-dive analysis. While an analyst might look at logs, a forensic investigator images hard drives and analyzes memory dumps to find deleted files or malware artifacts.
  • Threat Intelligence Analysts: This role looks outward. They research the Indicators of Compromise (IOCs) found by the team to determine if the attack is a known campaign by a specific Advanced Persistent Threat (APT) group.
  • IT Operations Liaison: A critical but often overlooked role. This is a system administrator who knows the environment intimately and has the access rights to implement the containment measures (e.g., changing firewall rules or disabling accounts) requested by the Security Analysts.

5.2 Communication and Escalation Protocols

The "Fog of War" is a major challenge during a cyber crisis. Without clear communication protocols, misinformation spreads, and critical decisions are delayed.

5.2.1 Internal Notification and Escalation

Not every security event warrants waking up the CEO. Organizations must establish Escalation Triggers and thresholds.

  • Internal Notification: Mechanisms must be in place to alert the team (e.g., PagerDuty, automated SMS).
  • Escalation Thresholds:
    • Low Severity: Handled by Tier 1 Analysts (e.g., a single workstation virus).
    • Medium Severity: Escalated to the Incident Lead (e.g., a server compromise).
    • High/Critical Severity: Escalated to Executives and Legal (e.g., data exfiltration, ransomware, or domain controller compromise).

5.2.2 Secure Out-of-Band (OOB) Communication

A critical mistake many teams make is using compromised infrastructure to discuss the incident.

  • The "Adversary is Listening" Principle: If an attacker has compromised the network or Active Directory, they likely have access to the corporate email system, Slack, or Microsoft Teams. Discussing remediation plans on these channels gives the attacker a heads-up to change tactics or destroy evidence.
  • Out-of-Band Tools: The CSIRT must establish a pre-defined communication channel that is completely separate from the corporate network.
    • Encrypted Messaging: Signal or Wickr are industry standards for secure, ephemeral messaging.
    • Voice: Burner phones or a dedicated cellular voice plan unrelated to the corporate VoIP system.
    • Storage: An off-network file repository (e.g., a secure cloud instance) for sharing sensitive evidence or reports.

5.3 The Incident Response Toolset

A carpenter is only as good as their tools. In Incident Response, tools are generally categorized by the type of evidence they target: Memory (RAM), Disk/File System, Network, or Endpoint Visibility.

5.3.1 Memory Forensics

RAM (Random Access Memory) is volatile; it disappears when the power is cut. However, it contains the most valuable data: encryption keys, running processes, and active network connections.

  • Volatility: The industry-standard open-source framework for memory forensics. It allows investigators to analyze a captured memory dump to see what was running on the computer at the exact moment of capture, even if the malware hid itself from the Task Manager.

5.3.2 Disk Forensics and Triage

  • FTK Imager: A fundamental tool for creating forensic images of hard drives. It copies data bit-by-bit to ensure evidence integrity without altering the original drive.
  • The Sleuth Kit (TSK) & Autopsy: TSK is a library of command-line tools for analyzing disk images, while Autopsy provides the graphical interface (GUI). It indexes files, recovers deleted data, and identifies web artifacts.
  • Eric Zimmerman's Tools: A suite of specialized tools for Windows artifact analysis. This includes Registry Explorer (for analyzing the Windows Registry), Timeline Explorer (for viewing CSV timelines), and ShellBags Explorer (for seeing which folders a user accessed).
  • KAPE (Kroll Artifact Parser and Extractor): A tool designed for speed. Instead of copying the whole drive, KAPE surgically targets the most important forensic artifacts (Registry hives, Event Logs, Browser History, Amcache) and parses them within minutes.

5.3.3 Endpoint Visibility and Remote Forensics

In a large enterprise with 10,000 laptops, you cannot physically touch every machine.

  • Velociraptor: An advanced endpoint visibility tool that allows the CSIRT to run queries across thousands of machines simultaneously (e.g., "Show me every computer that has a file named malware.exe in the Temp folder").
  • GRR Rapid Response: Google's remote live forensics framework. It allows for remote memory analysis and file collection across a fleet of machines.

5.3.4 Network Analysis

  • Wireshark: The de facto standard for network protocol analysis. It allows analysts to inspect traffic at a microscopic level (Packet Capture or PCAP) to see exactly what data was sent out of the network (exfiltration) or what commands were sent in (Command & Control).

5.4 SIEM Platforms: Architecture and Capabilities

The Security Information and Event Management (SIEM) system is the central nervous system of modern incident response. It aggregates logs from firewalls, servers, databases, and applications, correlating them to find patterns that no human could spot manually.

5.4.1 Why SIEM is Critical

Without a SIEM, an analyst would have to log into fifty different servers to check their individual logs. A SIEM provides a "Single Pane of Glass." It enables Correlation: connecting two seemingly unrelated events.

  • Example: A user badging into the building at 2:00 AM (Door Log) AND that same user accessing the payroll database (Database Log) might independently look innocent, but together they trigger a "Physical/Digital Anomaly" alert.

5.4.2 Splunk Architecture

Splunk is a leading commercial SIEM known for its powerful data ingestion and search capabilities. Its architecture consists of:

  • Forwarders: Lightweight agents installed on servers and endpoints that collect logs and send them to the indexer.
  • Indexers: The heavy lifters. They receive data, parse it, and store it in a searchable format (indices).
  • Search Heads: The user interface. Analysts use Search Heads to run queries against the Indexers and view dashboards.
  • SPL (Search Processing Language): Splunk uses a proprietary, pipe-based query language. It allows analysts to filter, transform, and visualize data effectively.
    • Concept: source="firewall" | stats count by dest_ip (This counts connections by destination IP).

5.4.3 The Elastic (ELK) Stack

The ELK Stack is a popular open-source alternative to Splunk. It is composed of three primary components:

  1. Logstash: The server-side data processing pipeline. It ingests data from multiple sources simultaneously, transforms it (parsing), and sends it to a "stash" like Elasticsearch.
  2. Elasticsearch: The search and analytics engine. It acts as the database, storing the logs in a JSON format that allows for near real-time search capabilities.
  3. Kibana: The visualization layer. This is the dashboard where analysts create charts, maps, and graphs to visualize the data stored in Elasticsearch.

5.4.4 Comparing Splunk vs. ELK

  • Splunk: Generally easier to set up out-of-the-box; robust support; proprietary licensing costs based on data volume.
  • ELK: Open-source (free core), but requires significant engineering effort to configure and maintain; highly customizable.

5.5 SIEM Use Cases in Incident Detection

Merely having a SIEM does not make an organization secure. It requires the development of specific use cases and content.

5.5.1 Correlation Rules

Correlation rules are "if-then" logic statements designed to detect known attack patterns.

Example

Example: "If a user fails to login 5 times in 1 minute (Brute Force) AND then successfully logs in (Breach), generate a High Severity Alert."

5.5.2 Anomaly Detection and Baseline Deviations

Attackers often use legitimate credentials, making them hard to spot with simple rules. Anomaly detection compares current activity against a historical baseline.

  • Example: "This server usually sends 50MB of data per day. Today it sent 5GB. Alert on 'Data Exfiltration Risk'."

5.5.3 User Behavior Analytics (UBA)

UBA is a more advanced form of anomaly detection focused on user identities. It builds a profile of "normal" behavior for every employee.

  • Example: If a marketing employee suddenly accesses the Engineering Code Repository at 3:00 AM, UBA flags this as a deviation from their peer group's normal behavior, potentially indicating a compromised account or an Insider Threat.

5.5.4 Threat Hunting

Reactive response waits for an alert. Threat Hunting is proactive. Analysts use the SIEM to search for "Indicators of Attack" (IoA) that automated rules missed. This might involve identifying "Long Tail" processes—software that is running on only one computer out of five thousand.

5.6 Documentation and Reporting

In incident response, if it is not written down, it did not happen. Proper documentation is essential for legal defense, insurance claims, and continuous improvement.

5.6.1 Specialized Incident Case Management

One of the most critical aspects of IR documentation is confidentiality.

  • Avoid General Ticketing Systems: Standard IT Service Management (ITSM) tools like Jira or ServiceNow are often inappropriate for sensitive incident tracking. If a standard system administrator or helpdesk technician can view a ticket titled "CEO Laptop Ransomware Investigation," the incident's confidentiality has been compromised.
  • Recommended Tools: Organizations should use specialized Case Management platforms with strict Access Control Lists (ACLs) limited to the CSIRT, Legal, and CISO.
    • TheHive: A popular open-source Security Incident Response Platform (SIRP) that allows multiple analysts to work on a case simultaneously while integrating with threat intelligence.
    • DFIR-IRIS: Another modern open-source collaborative investigation platform.
    • Commercial SOAR: Platforms like Cortex XSOAR or Splunk SOAR also provide secure case management features.

5.6.2 Evidence Documentation

  • Chain of Custody: This is the most critical legal document in forensics. It records who collected the evidence, when it was collected, where it was stored, and every person who has handled it since. A break in this chain can render evidence inadmissible in court.
  • Timestamping: Accurately recording when evidence was collected is vital for reconstructing the timeline.

[Image of Chain of Custody Form Example]

5.6.3 Incident Timeline Creation

Analysts must reconstruct the "Attack Timeline." This is a chronological sequence of events, normalizing timestamps across different time zones (e.g., converting all logs to UTC). This timeline helps determine the "Time to Compromise" and "Dwell Time."

5.6.4 Reporting and Lessons Learned

  • Executive Summary: A high-level, non-technical overview focused on business impact, cost, and risk.
  • Technical Incident Report: A detailed account including IP addresses, hashes, root cause, and remediation steps.
  • Legal/Regulatory Reporting: The Legal Liaison uses the documentation to fulfill obligations under laws like GDPR or HIPAA.
  • Lessons Learned: A post-mortem analysis to identify what went well and what failed, driving updates to the Incident Response Plan.

Chapter Summary

Effectively operating a CSIRT requires a synthesis of specialized human roles and sophisticated technological tools. While the Incident Commander and Analysts manage the tactical elements, tools like Volatility, KAPE, and Eric Zimmerman's suite provide the technical visibility needed to understand the breach. Underpinning this entire operation is the SIEM (whether Splunk or ELK), which aggregates data to detect anomalies through correlation and UBA. Finally, a rigorous documentation framework—using secure tools like TheHive and encrypted channels like Signal—ensures that the response itself does not become a security liability.

In Chapter 6, we will shift our focus to Incident Detection and Prevention, exploring how Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS) serve as the first line of defense.